It has been 22 years since the Blue Jays sniffed October Baseball. Who knew that when Joe Carter stepped up to the plate that October night, with Mitch “Wild Thing” Williams on the mound, that he would become Canada’s hero and cement his name in Baseball history. That three-run home run crowned the Blue Jays the 1993 World Series Champions and made them back-to-back champions of the world. The Blue Birds were flying high and it didn’t seem like anything could bring them down.
Twenty-two years later they have yet to make it back to the playoffs.
When Anthopoulos pulled the trigger on those blockbuster trades back in the 2012-2013 offseason, he did so with the intention of going for it. Mark Buehrle, Jose Reyes, Josh Johnson, Emilio Bonifacio, R.A Dickey. The Blue Jays loaded up on talent and piled on payroll in an effort to make a run in the American League East. The division seemed to be down and Anthopoulos felt like it was there for the taking. Unfortunately things did not go as planned as the Blue Jays would wind up winning only 74 games, finishing the season in last place.
However, Anthopoulos did not panic. He did not go Miami Marlins – Jeffrey Loria style on his ball club and his fan base and orchestrate a full-blown fire sale. Instead, he stayed on the same course and kept his talented core in place. He understood that his 3-4 punch of Bautista and Encarnacion was one of the most talented and feared in the game, and that with Jose Reyes leading off, and R.A Dickey and Mark Buehrle up top the rotation, he had a solid group of veteran players in place to build a championship caliber team around.
2014 passed by and the Blue Jays showed signs of improvement.The team increased its win total by 9 games and finished in 3rd place in the American League East, trailing only the Baltimore Orioles and the New York Yankees. Though Anthopoulos did not make any trades at that year’s July 31st non-waiver trade deadline, he now knew what he needed to do to put his team over the top. While some said he needed more talent to win, he knew he needed more winners to win. He needed to alter the culture of the clubhouse and he did just that. The additions of Josh Donaldson and Russel Martin in the offseason were aimed at bringing in talented players, with playoff experience, who exemplified leadership qualities that Anthopoulos felt were needed to propel the Blue Jays to the top. Colby Rasmus was let go and Adam Lind was traded to Milwaukee Brewers for right handed starter, Marco Estrada. Now, while everyone understood the Blue Jays had the offense to take them to the top, the question was always the pitching. Did the Toronto Blue Jays have the pitching that would allow them to win with their dynamite offense? Run support was not the concern, as it was all about run prevention. Without addressing the pitching staff, Anthopoulos did everything else he could to strengthen their run prevention. With the additions of Martin and Donaldson, and excellent role players like Ryan Goins and Kevin Pillar, the Blue Jays looked like a much more defensively sound ball club once opening day rolled around. Their only holes, you ask? Left field, shortstop, the starting rotation, and the bullpen. Quite a list.
While Jose Reyes was a great teammate with great flare and a true passion for the game, he was really starting to become a defensive liability. The routine play was starting to become less and less routine and this was really beginning to cost the Blue Jays runs. His -8 Defensive Runs Saved (DRS) at the All Star Break ranked near the bottom of the league, making it clear that while Reyes’ smile and infectious personality would be missed, a more defensively sound replacement at shortstop was definitely needed. July 28th would mark the day that this need would be addressed. Alex Anthopoulos, like a magician, had pulled off yet another blockbuster trade, acquiring talented, power-hitting shortstop Troy Tulowitzki from the Colorado Rockies, along with veteran right hander LaTroy Hawkins, in exchange for high-upside, right handed pitching prospects Jeff Hoffman, Jesus Tinoco, and Miguel Castro, as well as shortstop Jose Reyes. With one trade, Anthopoulos had managed to acquire a superstar in Tulowitizki; a franchise player who would not only bolster the team’s defense, but would also bolster them greatly from an offensive standpoint, both now, and for years to come. As well, a key factor greatly overlooked in this trade was how Anthopoulos had managed to bolster the team’s bullpen, as well, with the addition of Hawkins, a hard-throwing right hander. As a veteran of 21 years, Hawkins not only could help stabilize the bullpen, but could also provide a veteran presence in a bullpen filled with so much young blood.
While the trade was praised by some, it was highly critiqued as well, as many felt that Anthopoulos had used his primary bullets to strengthen an already stacked, star-studded offense that was leading the league by a wide margin in terms of runs scored, when it was the starting rotation that really could have used an upgrade. Ever since Aaron Sanchez had landed on the disabled list, his replacements in Felix Doubront, Scott Copeland and Matt Boyd had made 11 starts, going 2-9 with an ERA of 7.55, with less than four innings, on average, pitched per start. Anthopoulos knew these numbers and this made him understand that acquiring a starting pitcher was not a luxury, but was a necessity if the Blue Jays had any plans of contending. However, while most thought a modest upgrade, perhaps a Mike Leake or Aaron Harang was in store, Anthopoulos had bigger and better things in mind.
The Blue Jays had lacked a true ace ever since Roy Halladay had been traded from the team following the 2009 season, and Anthopoulos missed those days. He knew that acquiring an ace could change the complexion of his starting staff, and alter the landscape of the American League East. Having a pitcher that could match up against Chris Archer, Johnny Cueto, Felix Hernandez, Chris Sale and the other aces of the American League on any given night was something that Anthopoulos craved. However, with there really only being one ace pitcher left on the market, most thought this would be impossible to accomplish. With supply being so limited and the demand being so high, one could imagine just how high the price was, and with the Yankees and the Dodgers too on the lookout for an ace, chances looked slim for Toronto. However, on July 30th, Anthopoulos once again did what he does best and shocked the baseball world, acquiring ace left hander David Price from the Detroit Tigers in exchange for high-upside left handed pitching prospects Daniel Norris, Matt Boyd, and Jairo Labourt. Norris, a highly touted left hander who had made waves in the headlines for his talented play on the field and simple living off the field, was the Blue Jays No. 1 ranked prospect. However, Anthopoulos understood that the time was now.
With a lineup including Troy Tulowitzki, Josh Donaldson, Jose Bautista, Edwin Encarnacion, Russel Martin, Chris Colabello, Devon Travis, Justin Smoak, and Dioner Navarro, and with the addition of left fielder Ben revere, along with the M’s ace relief pitcher Mark Lowe, Anthopoulos understood that he had the pieces in place to make a real run.
Should you worry about Norris, Boyd and Labourt becoming the next Cole Hamels, Luke Hochevar, or Justin Nicolino? You can … but when David Cone made 11 starts to help the Blue Jays win the 1992 World Series, did you cringe every time Jeff Kent rounded the bases for the New York Mets or the San Francisco Giants?
Sure, Norris is a bright, hard throwing and talented left handed pitching prospect, with perhaps a very bright future, but Anthopoulos did not deal him to the Milwaukee Brewers for Mike Fiers or the Houston Astros for Scott Feldman.
They dealt him for a 6-foot-6 stud with a playoff pedigree, and a great history of thriving in the grueling American League East, and so far the move is paying off. Since falling to 1 game below .500 back on June 28th, the Blue Jays are 14-2 and have climbed from being 8 games back of the New York Yankees to being just a half a game back. With a huge sweep of the Yankees in New York just last weekend, and a huge series against them this weekend in Toronto, the city is buzzing and memories of the early 1990s are once again being lived in this city.
The fact of the matter is that the Blue Birds are once again back and are flying higher then they have in the last 22 years, and it is all thanks to one man: Mr. Alex Anthopoulos.